Red Boyle Heights – The Community Centers and the Red Scare Part 2

Along with the progressive friendly Soto-Michigan Jewish Community Center, another popular left-wing organization with important ties to the Boyle Heights and City Terrace areas since the early 1930s was the Jewish People’s Fraternal Order (JPFO). The JPFO was a section of the communist-aligned International Workers Order (IWO), a multiethnic mutual self-insurance fraternity that was nationally organized around ethnic-based branches or sections. The IWO was particularly popular with immigrant and African American members for its affordable insurance policies (life, health, dental, and burial) at a time when they were routinely denied or forced to pay exorbitant fees by most insurance companies. These benefits and policies were like those that the Workmen’s Circle (WC), another Jewish leftist fraternal order, provided to its own members.

In fact, the IWO was founded as a result of the 1920s ideological battles within the Workmen’s Circle between members associated with the Communist Party of the United States of America (CPUSA) and those more aligned with the Eugene Debs wing of the Socialist Party. The schism led to the communist members splitting off from the WC and establishing the International Workers Order in 1930. Of all the IWO “ethnic” or “language” sections, the Yiddish-language section (the JPFO) was the largest and most active.

As an insurance provider, the IWO introduced several innovative features like not employing sales representatives who took commissions, and in 1936, according to the National Institute of Health, the IWO was the first insurer in the United States to include birth control and gynecological care in its prepaid medical benefits.

International Workers Order (IWO) insurance brochure featuring African American actor and singer Paul Robeson. Courtesy of the Cornell University Library Digital Collection.

By the mid-1940s, the JPFO was serving Boyle Heights with several JPFO-run schools (“Give your children a progressive Jewish education”) operating under the auspices of the Bureau of Jewish Education, which was created by the L.A. Jewish Community Council in 1937. In 1949, a group of City Terrace parents affiliated with the JPFO came together to establish a multiracial cooperative (parents-owned) preschool in the Lincoln Heights area. This innovative preschool will be discussed with a little more information in the series’ postscript.  

Eastside Journal, 10/3/1945

With its insurance programs, children’s schools, and a City Terrace-based fraternal lodge (JPFO Lodge 253), the JPFO operated with a good degree of acceptance within mainstream “Jewish communal politics in Los Angeles,” according to Professor Deborah Dash Moore in her 1994 book To the Golden Cities: Pursuing the American Jewish Dream in Miami and L.A. “In 1945,” writes Moore, “the [Los Angeles Jewish Community] Council voted to expand its membership to include the city committee of the JPFO with its twelve lodges and three thousand members.”

Reflecting the IWO national policy, the local JPFO was an ardent supporter of the Black civil rights movement and participated in numerous protests throughout Los Angeles. One example was the 1946 protest against Bimini Baths, a popular 14-acre public bathhouse, plunge, and spa near Third and Vermont in the mid-city area. Built in 1903 and renowned for its natural hot springs, Bimini Baths also had a long history of turning away non-white visitors.

California Eagle, 5/9/1946

In 1948, spearheaded by JPFO Lodge 253, the JPFO founded and operated the City Terrace Cultural Center, making it the third Eastside area Jewish community center along with the Soto-Michigan JCC and the Menorah Center. The newly built center was equipped with an auditorium and stage, a playground, a basement game room, and accommodations for a classroom. The center was located at 3875 City Terrace Drive, just a block away from the rented space the JPFO was using at 1431 N. Miller Ave. Like the Soto-Michigan JCC in Boyle Heights, the City Terrace Cultural Center was also a welcoming Eastside venue for Jewish leftists.

   

Dedication of the new City Terrace Cultural Center, 1948. Courtesy of the LAPL photo collection.
Eastside Journal, 10-13-1948. Courtesy of Newspaper.com
In this 1952 aerial photo, the City Terrace Cultural Center is the square, white-roofed structure in the center where City Terrace Drive, Bonnie Beach Place, and Rogers Street intersect. Also visible is the eastbound Ramona Freeway, renamed the San Bernardino Freeway (I-10) in 1954. Courtesy of the UC Santa Barbara Aerial Photograph Collection.

With its mutual-aid benefits, civil rights activism, and several JPFO-run Jewish schools that reflected the area’s generally progressive sociopolitical values, the JPFO proved to be a popular organization well-integrated into the Jewish neighborhoods of Boyle Heights and City Terrace. But unlike the majority of the IWO/JPFO leadership, most of its working-class members didn’t identify as communists, but saw themselves mostly as progressive and practical members of a mutual-aid society, while the IWO itself appeared to steer clear of Stalinist politics which referred to Russia’s authoritarian dictator. And while the Soto-Michigan JCC, the Menorah Center, and two smaller, fledgling Jewish community centers in the Westside all operated under the guidelines established by the Los Angeles Jewish Community Council, each center was allowed a good degree of autonomy about its own programming.   

Above are newspaper notices about three events at the City Terrace Cultural Center. Regarding the Eastside Journal notice at the bottom, director and screenwriter Herbert Biberman was part of a group of blacklisted writers and directors known as the “Hollywood Ten” since 1947. In 1954, he directed the independent film Salt of the Earth, about a strike by Mexican American miners in New Mexico. The film was minimally distributed for decades due to government suppression efforts.

But the Los Angeles Welfare Federation was growing concerned with the JPFO’s membership within the Jewish Centers Association, especially since the JPFO often used the Soto-Michigan JCC facility before they established the City Terrace Cultural Center in 1948, and its members continued to be guest speakers and panelists. According to Professor Moore, in October of 1948, the Federation sent a directive to all its agencies that included a specific demand that the Soto-Michigan JCC ban the JPFO from using its facilities due to its affiliation with the International Workers Order (IWO). 

In response to the directive, Moore quotes the president of the Soto-Michigan JCC, Sam Bates, who argued: “Compliance with the Welfare Federation directive would remove what we feel is a very real segment of Jewish life from participation in Center activities.” Bates’ objection centered on the fact that the local JPFO had already founded several popular schools, operated the City Terrace Cultural Center, and provided a popular insurance policy program. In 1944, the JPFO even contributed efforts toward the community goal of selling enough U.S. War Savings Bonds to have a B-12 bomber christened the “Spirit of City Terrace,” as there was already a “Spirit of Boyle Heights” bomber. (By 1944, communists in the U.S. supported the war effort because the Soviet Union was a tactical ally fighting Nazi Germany.) Considering their degree of community participation, Moore noted:“Jewish communists in the JPFO could not be excluded from the Boyle Heights community without substantially changing its character.”

Courtesy of Newspapers.com

But matters took a dire turn for the future of the JPFO in June 1950 when the Jewish War Veterans of the United States brought accusations before the Los Angeles Jewish Community Council (JCC), an umbrella organization that represented an array of Jewish organizations throughout Los Angeles. The veterans group charged that the JPFO was not a “real Jewish organization,” thus not qualified to receive funding under the council’s guidelines. After the JPFO pleaded their case in open hearings over several months, the L.A. Jewish Community Council voted to expel the JPFO in the spring of 1951, which included fourteen JPFO lodges and the City Terrace-based Emma Lazarus lodge. The council offered the possibility of reinstatement if the JPFO lodges severed their ties with the International Workers Order. Moore’s succinct summation of the JPFO’s expulsion was simply, “Jewish Communists had enjoyed a brief five years within the Jewish communal fold.”

California Eagle, 6/16/1950. Courtesy of Newspapers.com

In March 1951, the Jewish Centers Association informed the centers that it would be up to each center to decide which subjects would be appropriate to discuss at its facility. According to the board minutes, as cited by Moore, the JCA concluded: the Boards of Jewish Centers must recognize the change of public attitudes which has developed in our country with regard to the political activity of individuals and organizations publicly charged with being unfriendly to American democracy.  

In 1954, under intense pressure from the federal government, the IWO was forced to disband and liquidate all its holdings after the U.S. Department of Justice charged the IWO with being a subversive communist front, while the State of New York moved to revoke its insurance charter, forcing the IWO to sell all its remaining assets.    

Los Angeles Times, 1/17/1954. Courtesy of Newspapers.com.

The postwar demographic changes occurring in Boyle Heights, which influenced funding decisions for the community centers, added further pressure to the already cloudy future of the Soto-Michigan JCC. With Boyle Heights experiencing a declining Jewish population as many Eastside Jews started moving out to the Westside and to the San Fernando Valley, the L.A. Jewish Community Council and the Jewish Centers Association insisted that limited dollars and resources had to be reallocated to these emerging Jewish enclaves, where the demand was growing. This was happening while the Soto-Michigan JCC was still booming in the early 1950s, in large part because of the participation of local non-Jewish residents.

In 1952, the Jewish Community Council made the decision to reassign the Menorah Center’s religious instruction programming to the Soto-Michigan JCC, while moving to close the Menorah Center permanently. In that same year, the Soto-Michigan JCC, remaining in the same location, dissolved itself and transferred its assets to what was now renamed the Eastside Jewish Community Center. Staff members, including director Joseph Esquith, were eventually transferred to other centers, suggesting that the move to fold operations into one center was also used to remove the more radical staff members from the Soto-Michigan JCC.

The Tidings, 10/28/1966. Courtesy of Newspapers.com

Meanwhile, the Menorah Center’s board announced that it would continue to operate and remain open to everyone in the community despite no funding from the Jewish Community Council. The Menorah Center continued to routinely hold community fundraising drives while also pleading for funds from groups like the Community Service Organization (CSO) and the district office of Councilman Ed Roybal. The center continued to operate, but times were lean, and by 1957, the Menorah Center closed permanently. In 1961, the building was sold to the Salesians, a Roman Catholic religious order. After several years of refurbishing, the building was reopened in 1966 as the Salesians Boys Club but is known today as the Salesians Boys and Girls Club.

Part 3 of this series about the Jewish community centers will focus on the continuing story of the Eastside Jewish Community Center, formerly the Soto-Michigan Jewish Community Center, and how it emerged as a city-wide model for intercultural programming in multiracial Boyle Heights.